The publication of the Immigration White Paper revealed the Government’s highly anticipated policy direction on overseas talent and international students last week, outlining a number of policy shifts which will combine to create substantial impact.
The Paper makes notable strides in recognising the need for skilled overseas talent and seeks to align the UK’s migration system to its Industrial Strategy. This is a positive policy direction that we welcome. But, the forthcoming Bill will also bring challenges, introducing a number of policy shifts that will affect universities and businesses hiring global talent – and which will cumulatively result in major change. From unexpected levies to tightened restrictions on visa and settlement terms, this piece digests the highly trailered reforms, and examines their risks.
Our diverse university sector is one of the UK’s greatest global strengths and an important factor attracting businesses investment. This strength is not just within the most elite universities, but across the breadth of the system and country. Increasingly, innovative clusters of businesses can be found in all parts of the UK, often concentrated in close proximity to a local university and enjoying reciprocally beneficial collaboration and knowledge exchange, and creating a delicate skills supply-and-demand partnership.
To achieve our national ambitions, the UK needs an approach to immigration that enables a strong and globally-connected university sector, and which meets the skills needs of our innovative businesses. International students play a critical role in achieving this. Their economic influence goes beyond supporting universities financially; their funds cross-subsidise important university activities, they diversify campuses and enrich learning experiences, and build the UK’s soft power.
The changes in detail
- Employers to face higher costs for international talent, as contradicting policies undermine access to skills
In the employment space, policy direction is clear – the Government is tightening immigration for lower-skilled workers, whilst seeking to enable opportunities for higher-skilled talent. The detail, however, looks set to undermine positive action.
To attract highly skilled workers to the UK, the Paper seeks to increase opportunities and applications to existing high-talent routes such as the Global Talent Visa – particularly within strategic industries. We’re pleased to see the retention and further support for the High Potential Individual, Innovator Founder and Global Talent visas, in their existing forms, and the links being made between these and the Industrial Strategy sectors.
Alongside this, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology is actively launching a £50m programme to attract international researchers to the UK. The scheme will fund research grants and relocation, with an initial aim of supporting around 10 teams of researchers, with scope for expansion. This is a popular move – research from the Campaign for Science and Engineering (CaSE) finds the public supports immigration into the UK’s research and development (R&D) sector, and it is an opportunity NCUB has strongly advocated for, particularly whilst researchers in the US face hostility and funding uncertainty.
However, undermining this positive action, the Paper raises barriers to the employment of international talent. It sets out requirements for employers to “boost domestic talent and skills if they want to recruit from abroad”. Details of how they must do this are scant, but the Paper warns that employers who do not make this investment would be banned from sponsoring visas.
If this ‘boost’ comes in addition to the forthcoming Growth and Skills levy – which will capture income from larger employers to spend on skills initiatives including apprenticeships – it could act as a double tax, punishing our most innovative businesses and undermining the UK’s attractiveness as a hub for new companies and investment.
Coming alongside a rise in employer’s sponsorship cost – up to a high of £6,600 for larger firms – it forms a perfect storm. The reforms threaten affordability and attractiveness. The headwinds facing employers and driving their declining investment in skills in recent years have also led to a general decline in business investment in R&D, underlining these challenges.
The UK’s most R&D-driven and innovative companies and universities thrive by attracting top global talent – researchers, entrepreneurs, and innovators. The Government must remove barriers to employers recruiting top international talent – not add to them.
- Reforms to graduate visa rules less damaging than feared
Following rumoured plans of severe cuts to the pathways allowing international students and graduates to work in the UK, the announced reforms appear less damaging than previously feared. Nevertheless, they send a strong message, and could have severe consequences.
The White Paper has outlined plans to reduce the duration of time international graduates can stay in the UK on the sponsorship-free Graduate Visa to 18 months, down from the current 24 months, as part of a broader effort to reduce low-skilled migration and manage asylum claims. In this timeframe, graduates will be able to seek qualifying employment to transition to another visa – such as the Skilled Worker route.
Against a challenging political backdrop, rumours hinted the plans would raise barriers to international students seeking employment in the UK post-study – and possibly remove the route all together. Successful advocacy in this space, including by NCUB, appears to have led to positive concessions, at a vital time for the university sector.
Graduates are the shoots of tomorrow’s highly skilled workforce, and it is positive this cohort has retained the ability to secure meaningful graduate employment that contributes to the UK economy. On average, this takes 5 to 6 months, meaning the reduction is unlikely to significantly affect either international student numbers or graduate employment outcomes. The government’s own technical annex estimates the change will lead to a reduction of 12,000 students and 400 dependents. To put that in perspective, nearly 670,000 international students were enrolled in UK institutions during the 2021–22 academic year.
The move does, however, land a political statement. The reduced offering and strong political messaging around immigration reduction has the damaging potential to disincentivise future international learners and workers from studying at a UK university, by reducing the attractiveness of both the post-study pathway and the UK as a place to live, study and work.
Institutions are already facing financial pressures compounded by reduced international student numbers following reforms in 2024 – which disallowed international students from bringing dependents to the UK and led to an 85% drop in dependent applications. The sector has absorbed a 15.6% decline in income over the past two years, totalling an estimated £1.1bn loss.
Further restrictions in this space, without reforming the built-in interdependency of international student tuition income within the university funding model, will simply undermine the financial stability of universities and their ability to contribute to economic growth. And, if large numbers of these students are increasingly questioning the UK as a study destination, it raises questions over the UK’s strength as a world-leading knowledge economy.
- Universities face uncertainty over coming levy
In an unexpected move, the Government also appears to be seeking to redistribute the income raised by international student tuition and associated economic benefits. It is introducing a levy on higher education provider income from international students, which it states will then be reinvested into the higher education and skills system.
Levy funds could cross-subsidise income among universities with greater domestic students and a smaller international contingent – as well as supporting the government’s place agenda. However, coming at a time when income from international students is so critical for universities’ struggling operations and valuable economic activities, alarm bells are ringing over concerns as to how this will work and who will actually stand to benefit.
NCUB calls for urgent clarity on the detail of this new levy, ahead of the distant, promised date of the Autumn Budget.
The White Paper calls on universities to take greater responsibility for the international students they sponsor and tightening the Basic Compliance Assessment (BCA) metrics that enable them to do so. These reforms increase the minimum pass requirements of the BCA metrics, introduce a RAG rating to evaluate university responsibility and performance, and create an ‘action plan’ approach for non-compliance, reducing recruitment and sponsorship rights within those institutions.
These moves go with the tide of Department for Education (DfE) messaging, warning the university sector to deliver operational efficiencies and improve access and educational delivery. Response from the sector is already underway, but these criticisms fail to acknowledge the critical limiting factors of the below-inflation domestic tuition fee cap, below-cost research funding, and high inflation – pressures the Government could help alleviate.
- Improved labour market evidence
The White Paper has announced the formation of an independent Labour Market Evidence Group (LME Group), comprising of the Industrial Strategy Advisory Council, Skills England representatives and devolved nation skills bodies (such as Medr), the Migration Advisory Committee, and the Department for Work and Pensions group on workforce inactivity. We strongly support the development of this group, which will play a key role in mapping the skills landscape to the Industrial Strategy.
Assessing the bigger picture of workforce supply, participation, and international dependence, the group will capture and review data on migration patterns, domestic workforce participation, sector trends and overseas reliance. This proactive coalition has the potential to form important policy initiatives that upskill domestic workers, improve opportunities and working conditions, and catalyse the key ambitions of the Industrial Strategy, to drive economic participation, productivity and growth.
Risks hide behind unexpected corners
Much of the narrative in the public domain has focused on the growth in lower-skilled immigration and reliance on overseas recruitment. In response to these trends and political pressures, the Home Office is lowering eligibility thresholds within the points based system to 2020 levels – Level 6 (known as RQF 6, equivalent to degree level), up from RQF 3 (A-level equivalent). Salary thresholds will rise, as they use this as a mechanism to drive up domestic employment in lower-skilled roles and improve pay conditions.
Although this appears less relevant to universities and innovation spaces, a changing workforce in areas like social care could have significant consequences to local government funding, possibly raising costs and straining already creaking budgets. This eventuality could create harmful knock-on impacts to locally funded schemes supporting collaboration and skills development – it’s a space we’ll continue to watch.
NCUB has been advocating loudly for a government position that is open and attractive to top talent, and which enables the delivery and expansion of our nation as a global knowledge and innovation leader. In a recent letter to Sir Keir Starmer, we warned of the risks associated with the moves made in the White Paper, and have joined forces with innovation bodies to raise these concerns.
Whilst much can change as policy direction within the Paper becomes developed into legislation, NCUB will continue to advocate on behalf of UK universities and businesses, for the benefit of national innovation. We will be working with government officials on how education, research and innovation can transform the UK’s future, and the role that strategic and targeted immigration plays therein.